Tuesday, May 06, 2008

What Legal Standard Is This I Wonder?

Wis. bars who banned drink specials win price-fixing case

The state Supreme Court says Madison bars who agreed to eliminate drink specials are not guilty of an illegal price-fixing conspiracy.

The court refused to reinstate a lawsuit brought by drinkers claiming they were overcharged as a result of the 2002 agreement by bars to stop serving drink specials on weekend nights.

More than 20 bars adopted the voluntary ban to thwart a stricter one the city was considering at the time.

In a 3-1 decision, the court said the bars' actions are immune from state antitrust law since they acted under pressure from city regulators who wanted to crack down on binge drinking.
[emphasis added]

Is this saying "Yes, you broke the law...but you had a REALLY good reason, so it's OK."??????

One wonders what the judges were drinking.

No comments: